Posted on

Sony WM-DDII, WM-DDIII, WM-DD30, WM-DD33 frequency response improvement, or “When megabass becomes useless”

Without doubts, Sony DD series walkmans are the most popular of all personal cassette players. This popularity is not only build quality but also because of sound quality that these walkmans have.. or should have?

As most of you know, Sony WM-DC2 or WM-D3 are the best sounding walkmans ever made (if we forgot about heavy D6C). But what about other DD models? Do they also sound so well? No, there is huge difference between them and above mentioned models. Why is that?

  • Head used. While DC2 or D3 use amorphous head, other  models use just permalloy head. But I cannot hear well higher frequencies, where these heads are excellent. And anyway, DC2 sounds much better
  • Head wear. Those permalloy heads are soft and wear very fast. Most DD walkmans have some hours played.
  • Cicruit design and components used. DC2 uses discrete preamp stage while other DD models use IC preamp.

No, there must be also something else.

Frequency response

I measured FR of several WM-DDII to DD33 and result is very surprising. They’re absolutely missing bass, dynamics in lower frequency range is very poor. I am not talking about few decibels. Output level is 20dB lower at 20Hz and at frequency of 63 Hz it is still not in acceptable -3dB level. 

In case of DD30 and DD33, this problem is compensated by megabass circuit. When turned on, signal at lower frequencies is amplified.. but how? This effect is most evident at about 60 Hz. With cheap headphones, it improves sound a lot. But what happens if you use quality headphones/earphones? Sound is dull, it is amplified where it shouldn’t be. With megabass turned on, sound is unlistenable. With megabass turned off, it is missing bass. Frequency response is not flat. 

When you look at graph, you can see it clearly (the blue line marked as 10uF). I used FR tape and oscilloscope to measure level at various frequencies. I tested it on several DD models, all with the same result. All were tested after complete recap. Do you want better results? Buy WM-DC2! Or use the following modification.

Simple modification to get flat response

Note: these modifications will be audible only when high quality headphones are used. Their real frequency response lower-end must be 20-30Hz, not on paper only

All four DD models have one thing common. They use BA3304F as EQ preamplifier. The capacitor connected in series with the gain-setting resistor between the NF pin and the bias pin, is the bypass capacitor. The value of this capacitor determines the bass characteristics. Value of this capacitor is 10uF. In case of DDII and DDIII models, it is tantalum capacitor. As the tantalum capacitor ages, it causes issues in FR response. Look at the blue line, and peak at about 100 Hz. Replacing this capacitor to new one removed this issue but the problem with poor bass response remained. In later models, DD30 and DD33 Sony used electrolytic capacitors instead of tantalum ones as they probably knew about this issue.

Frequency response at lower frequencies can be simply improved by using capacitor of higher value. I used 47uF instead of 10uF with perfect results. See the ref line marked as 47uF.

The bass frequency response can be improved little more by using higher value output capacitors – the ones connected between headphone amplifier IC and headphone connector. Modern polymer electrolytes are of very high quality and can have high capacity at small size. I recommend to use 560uF/2.5V instead of 220uF/4V. It is useful especially when small impedance earphones are used, e.g. 32 Ohm. This will improve bass at 20Hz about 6 dB.

Posted on

How to improve belt quality

Belt is critical component of every cassette player. That’s why choosing correct belt for your cassette device is very important.

Belts can be used on various places of your cassette decks, for example main belt, inter-capstan belt, mode belt, counter belt… Some are square, some are flat. The most discussed belts are those that affect audio quality. Old good belt producers are gone forever and current belt producers cannot make belts of quality required by sensitive cassette deck mechanics.

These are three parameters that have to be taken into consideration, when choosing right belt:

  • belt quality
  • belt dimensions – circumference, width and thickness
  • belt material

Using incorrect belt will have negative effect to tape stability, wow/flutter, mechanics noise and parts wear. Each cassette transport is designed to use belt of specific parameters. It is always good to find balance between belt length, belt thickness and belt material. Some mechanics require elastic , some require harder belts. Some are more sensitive to correct belt, some less. It is given by design.

There is wide choice of generic belts of various lengths and types on today’s market. There are suppliers of generic belts, like ASWO here in Europe, or turntableneedles in US. They are very cheap, optically they look very good. The only problem is that their surface quality is not sufficient enough to meet specs given by manufacturers of cassette decks. Some transports, like Aiwa dual capstan transport, are very sensitive to belt quality.

Fortunately, quality of flat belts can be significantly improved using method of sanding. There can be several reasons why the belt is not perfect.

One of them is surface not smooth enough. It does not necessarily need to be visible by naked eye. You can feel it when you move your finger along the belt surface.

It is possible to use this DIY method using very cheap tools, at home environment. The only tools that you need is 600 grit sanding bands rotary tool. As a result, surface of such  belt will be smooth, uniform and flat.

By using this method, I could reduce wow/flutter from 0.07% (10 sec peaks) WRMS to 0.03%, by just adjusting belt A of Aiwa XK-009 cassette deck. This method was tested in various cassette decks with similar results.

Warning! Not all belt materials are suitable for this modification. EPDM, NBR materials can be easily sanded. On the other hand, neoprene is very difficult to sand. 

Belt improvement procedure

Another one is thickness inconsistency. 

It means that the belt thickness varies around the belt length. Quality original belts vary less than 0.005 mm. In case of  currently produced belts, it is a question of luck. When I ordered new belts of various dimensions from my manufacturer, in case of some dimensions, the belts are perfect while in case of some other dimensions they are very badly. Sometimes also quality varies within the same size.  I measured some old Sony and Aiwa belts and thickness uniformity was always within 0.002 mm. In case of new belts, I never found better than 0.008 mm. 0.01 to 0.015 is typical. And some belts from crap producers vary within 0,2 mm! So what can we do to improve it? It is not difficult but it requires patience and a time. And you will need the sanding rotary tool described above plus quality micrometer with constant push force.

I use to measure belt thickness cm by cm and I mark place where the thickness is largest. I repeat measurement to confirm it.

Then, I use the sanding tool to adjust thickness around the marked place. I move up and down the rotary tool, around the marked place.

Then I repeat the whole process again until I find another maximum thickness. I repeat the steps until thickness varies within 0.005 mm range. 

It need a little practice but result can be very good.

Posted on 1 Comment

WM-D6C DC-DC converter fixed

For many of us it is very famous problem. Reversed DC polarity and … 
There were many discussions on this topic. Here I would like to discuss two possible solutions, with simple TO-DO for everyone

1st. possibilty

Replace whole converter by modern type, sold here and there on eBay. You can find various 5V to 12V converters, or even anything to 12V converters. They’re small, much smaller than the original one. They’re more efficient. They can deliver more power. So why not to use them easily?
The answer is simple – they inerfere with internal circuits of D6C. You need to build ground shielding around it. More, their output voltage isn’t “clean” enough and it requires another filtering. Impossible? No, it just requires some time spent. Does anyone have experiences?

2nd. posibility

Repair the old one. Is it easy? Yes and no. The most difficult part is to remove the converter from PCB and open the original shield. It is difficult but everyone will know how to do it as soon as he tries.
I will rather describe how to troubleshoot the circuit that is inside.

Here is crop from service manual. It is just symbolic circuit and it has some basic mistakes. But it is very good start point.

Transformer and transistor on the left side create oscillator. Diode on the top is rectifier. Transistor and diodes on the right create stabilizer. When you reverse polarity, three parts can be burned – the ones marked with red letters and transformer. However, the wire on the transformer is much thicker than on the 33uH coil, that’s why it will survive. In most cases, it is necessary to replace both red parts:


1. Inductor: in blue circle (33uH, bigger version)

2. Transistor: in blue circle.

Instead of hard to get 2SD1048 you can use BC817 as 1:1 replacement. Well, the older one is little stronger (700mA vs 500mA) but in this application it doesn’t matter that much.

It is good to have right soldering station to be able to solder SMD parts. Or ask someone who can.

I hope you find this article useful. Any comments are welcome.

Marian

Posted on

Wow and Flutter – my know-how

Hi.

I would like to post my experiences regarding typical problems with tape speed variations. I have fixed about 200 walkmans from Sony, Panasonic and Aiwa. However, I collect and repair only full-metal body autoreverse models made cca. after 1989. But most of my observations are valid for any model.

Many people think that these problems are related mostly to wrong belt used, but my experiences are little different. So here is my knowledge listed in the lowest to the highest probability order.

Continue reading Wow and Flutter – my know-how
Posted on

Sony DD series step-by-step repair guide for dummies

Sony DD series (direct drive) walkmans are very popular among portable cassette players because of their high quality construction, excellent fully analog sound quality – and great timeless design.

Although they’re well built, they will not work within specs without proper service. Because they’re 30+ years old, most of them will have some common issues by now.

In this manual I will give very detailed step-by-step instructions on how to fix all common problems – and recommendations on maintenance tasks to do, to avoid future problems. With the help of this manual you should be able to do proper service on any DD unit. I’ve fixed more than 200 DD units and will present my know-how and best practices, discovered through the years. I will try to make it as complete as possible.

This manual is suitable for everyone with at least basic technical skills. Experienced technicians will also find useful information here.

Continue reading Sony DD series step-by-step repair guide for dummies
Posted on 5 Comments

Panasonic RQ-S series walkmans – complete step-by-step repair guide

Dear all walkman fans,

from time to time I read here in various posts, how difficult it is to fix those small ultra narrow walkmans and bring them back to the specs. I must say it is not true. Most of them were designed to be serviced easily. Yes, they’re small, sometimes just little bigger than the cassette itself. But after you open them, you will see that there all is perfectly organized and parts are not that small as one could expect. From my experience, they’re much easier to fix than most bigger devices, such as boomboxes. Why? Boomboxes are made of plastics, their construction is cheap, with mix of wires, etc.

Continue reading Panasonic RQ-S series walkmans – complete step-by-step repair guide